Variability of Spleen and Mesenteric Lymph Node in Control Cynomolgus Monkeys ( Macaca fascicularis) from Nonclinical Safety Studies: A Retrospective Assessment.

We assessed the variability of spleen and mesenteric lymph node (MLN) microscopic observations and the correlations of these observations with other study data from 478 control cynomolgus monkeys from 53 routine nonclinical safety studies. Spleen weight parameters (absolute and relative to body or brain weights) were highly variable both within a control group on an individual study (up to 5.11-fold) and among animals with the same light microscopic observation. Grades for microscopic observations were also highly variable. The most frequent microscopic observations for spleen were changes in the size and number of germinal centers (58%), acidophilic (hyaline) material in lymphoid follicles (52%), and compound lymphoid follicles (20%). The most frequent microscopic observations in the MLN were eosinophil infiltrates (90%), changes in size and number of germinal centers (42%), and brown pigment (21%). The only meaningful relationships ( r2 > 0.3) were positive correlations between reticuloendothelial hyperplasia and malarial pigment in the spleen and between each of these observations and spleen weight parameters. We conclude that determination of test article-related effects on the immune system in routine monkey toxicology studies requires careful consideration and a weight-of-evidence approach due to the low numbers of animals/group, the inherent variability in spleen and MLN parameters, and the infrequent correlation among immune system-related end points.

Maturity-related Variability of the Thymus in Cynomolgus Monkeys (Macaca fascicularis).

Terminal body weights (TBWs), thymus weight parameters, and thymus morphology were retrospectively evaluated in 453 cynomolgus monkeys assigned to control groups on nonclinical toxicity studies. Morphology of bone, ovary, and testis/epididymis were used to determine maturity status of individual animals. There was no correlation between TBW and thymus weight (absolute and/or relative to TBW or brain weight). Thymus weight parameters and grades of decreased lymphocytes in the thymus were highly variable in immature animals compared to mature animals. There was also high (up to 11-fold) variability of thymus weight parameters within a given control group on the same study (generally 3 or 4 animals per sex). Several parameters evaluated had more pronounced age-related changes in males when compared to females. Our results demonstrate the inherent variability of thymus weight parameters and morphologic observations for cynomolgus monkeys on toxicology studies. Changes in thymus parameters in cynomolgus monkeys are unreliable indicators of immunomodulation or immunotoxicity in the absence of other relevant findings. Therefore, the thymus parameters commonly evaluated in preclinical safety assessments should not be the primary data set used to determine the presence of a direct test article-related effect on the immune system.